Monday, January 12, 2015

Insignia NS-SP213, Best Buy did something right... and cheap

Insignia NS-SP213 Best Buy did something right... and cheap

For the most part all of us who review cheap speakers have been sticking to products you can buy on Amazon. I left that comfort zone and went outside, drove to the dreaded Best Buy and picked up a pair of their cheap bookshelf speakers, the Insignia NS-SP213. The previous generation of Insignia bookshelf speakers, the NS-B2111, got a good amount of fan fair for a being a cheap bookshelf speaker during a time before the Dayton B652's or anyone looking at $100 speakers ever heard of Andrew Jones.

So was Best Buy successful in producing a good sub $100 speakers? I think so. In fact at the retail price of $69.99 and a sale price of $49.99 they are tough to beat.


Detailed album of Speaker Disassembly pictures. 
http://imgur.com/a/QkOFs

The NS-SP231 are your basic black cabinet speaker. At its retail price, there really isn't a huge number of options; and they all are black. But this is easily the prettiest of the bunch. Not shown is the keyhole mount to hang them on a wall.

With Grill
http://i.imgur.com/6tA59bm.jpg

Without Grill
http://i.imgur.com/IcTX9gZ.jpg

Here is it, next to the Dayton B652
http://i.imgur.com/wM2V4Iv.jpg

Taking apart the speaker to inspect the drivers and construction proved a little more interesting than expected.

What kind of sorcery is this?
http://i.imgur.com/dGAOaNQ.jpg

Basic black stamped basket midrange driver
http://i.imgur.com/11uC9V7.jpg

But! A nice, real crossover. No full range mid and cap on the tweeter. The only other speaker in this price range that has something like this would be the Micca MB42x's at $79.99. I also like the molex plug on the tweeter, made my life a little easier while testing.
http://i.imgur.com/NtAEoum.jpg

Tiny bit of corner bracing on the front baffle, and the smiley face port.
http://i.imgur.com/3yxbXwL.jpg

Figured out why my screw driver stood up on it's own. Dat magnet.
http://i.imgur.com/hpM13B4.jpg

For the money, this is a well made speaker. Much better put together than many of the units it would be competing against (Dayton, Polk, Monoprice), and not far behind the Pioneer BS-22's or Infinity p153's. Certainly better than the much more expensive and beloved TEAC LS-H265.

So how did it all sound? Pretty damn good for the most part.  

Insignia NS-SP213 Frequency Response Graphs
http://imgur.com/a/98x8f


Here are the individual driver frequency responses
http://i.imgur.com/JyIRSMk.png

It looks like the drivers are crossed over at about 2.5khz. I didn't find any official documentation that listed it.

Grills are a killer on these things and just make the treble all manners of wonky (as seen in multiple measurements in the album). I recommend taking them off. The speaker is good looking enough that the drivers don't need to be hidden.

Port looks to be tuned around 80hz, so these wont be bass monsters.

Now for the important par; the 1 meter measurements.
http://i.imgur.com/FamEvwM.png

As seen in most of my indoor measurements the hump at 150hz is present. The midrange might be just a touch thin, but never bloated or too forward.

Aside from the dip at 350hz, this speaker is +/- 3 db form 150hz (which matched the roll off of the close mic measurement) to 18khz when measured outdoors. And measured pretty similar indoors until about 400hz where room modes get more active.

When measured @1m outdoors the port doesn't seem to be outputting much volume.

Compared to some of the other speakers in the segment, the Insignia's compare with very well. I found them to be very similar to the TEAC LS-H265 in over all tonality; however they do lack the good bass response of the TEAC's. The TEAC's best the Insignia overall, but at 3x the cost.

Unfortunately I've seemed to have lost my .mdat file with the TEAC's outdoor response so I can't overlap them until I get a chance to measure them again. But here is the original TEAC measurements for comparison.

http://i.imgur.com/MwMRnfY.png

The Insignia's are far and away better than any of the Polk budget offerings (R15,R150 and T15). Much better than the terrible Dayton B452, and lack the harshness that can be heard in the happy accident of the Dayton B652's. I don't have better measurements of the Sony SS-1000, but I'd be welling to bet the Insignia's best those also, the Sony's were very muted with in the upper registers.

I know, call me crazy and stupid, from a personal enjoyment stand point, I liked them more than the Pioneer BS22's, but I personally find the BS22's to be too warm for my taste, and slightly muddy in the bass.

With the understanding that the Insignia's weak bass output points to them needing to be paired with a subwoofer, I would pick them over the Pioneers for myself.


TL;DR

Don't count out the Insignia NS-SP213 just because it's cheap and found at a mass market consumer electronic store. It's a good speaker that everyone shopping this price point should look into. The fact that they can be found locally for many people and have an easy return policy should be an added bonus. Without a doubt they would make an excellent surround speaker.



53 comments:

  1. You should do a review on the JBL Loft 30 and Loft 40... They sound great

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I did review the JBL loft 30's and found them to be rather unimpressive. You can read about it more here:

      http://averagejoeaudiophile.blogspot.com/2014/08/battle-of-harman-kardon-budget-brands.html

      Delete
  2. I literally just bought these last night along with a pair of Polk T15's because they sounded OK for the price. I found your review today after trying to get some more info about the Polk's. My store didn't even have the Insignia's hooked up with the rest of the bookshelf speakers, probably because they wouldn't sell so many of the high priced Klipsch or Bose if they did.

    The Polk's have some good bass, but I also found them lacking in the highs and midrange. I was going to wait to hook up the Insignia's because I didn't expect too much from them. Your review convinced me otherwise, and they sound great even though the bass doesn't have the same thump as the Polk's. I guess you can't have everything at this price, but now I'll have some extra cash to spend on a subwoofer. For $69 plus tax I think these blow away the Micca MB-42X that I've been demo-ing for the last few weeks. I'm so glad you pointed out these value speakers.

    If you're up for another trip to Best Buy, let me suggest that you take a look at the Insignia NS-SH513 compact CD shelf system which occasionally goes on sale for 79 to 99 ($120 normally). That system includes a nice set of speakers that have a 4" driver (at least I think so because the grill doesn't seem to come off.) It's a shame they don't sell these separately, because they sounded pretty good on my desktop (detached from their mothership and paired with a cheap Lepai amp). Unfortunately I got the itch to upgrade, and I have also done way too much window shopping on Amazon. Trying them out at home is the only way to know. Anyway, the Polk's are going back to the store now. Nice review and thanks for championing affordable audio. Cheers!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for the awesome comment. I'm glad you like the Insignia's; overall I really enjoyed my time with them and I think they are a great value. Pick up a small subwoofer to go with them and they make a great budget 2.1 system.

      Delete
    2. Any suggestions for a sub to pair with these? I'm mainly using these for music at my desk so I want some clean and tight bass that won't make everything sound like mud. I've had my eyes on the Yamaha YST-SW012 which is going for $89 on Amazon at the moment. My other considerations are the Martin Logan Dynamo 300 or perhaps the Dayton SUB-1000.. So many options. Oh well, at least I'm doing my part to stimulate the economy.

      Delete
    3. I don't know anything about the Yamaha sub, but the Amazon reviewers seem to like it. I do like Dayton subs and have used the 800 and 1200 in the past and think they are solid choices for a budget subwoofer. But the Dynamo is the best of the bunch. If you can afford it, I would go for the Dynamo.

      Delete
    4. Cool. I picked up the Dayton 800 since it was on sale and it arrived a few days ago. First impressions are that it sounds a little muddy when I use the dedicated subwoofer output on my soundcard. Maybe I should use the speaker level inputs passed from my Lepai since I'm using that to control volume anyway? Or do I just need to give it more time to break in? I didn't go with the Dynamo because it was out of stock on Amazon at the time, and the Dayton was about $40 less so it was an easy compromise. Also I've been eating a lot of return shipping charges to Amazon lately and thinking that it may not be the best place to buy speakers (especially ones that you've never heard). For example, I just returned a pair of Micca MB-42X that I found to be completely lackluster. Have you had a chance to try those yet?

      Delete
  3. I would try the speaker level inputs also on the Dayton. But remember, it's a very entry level budget subwoofer. It will be much better than any PC speaker system or HTIB subwoofer, but at $90 or so, it can all do so much.

    I haven't used the MB42x but I do have the MB42x-C (the MTM/Center Channel speaker). I need to give them some more listening time to give a better opinion.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hello. I doubt you will ever see this post, but I saw someone claiming this speaker was made by Yamaha. Do you have any information about that being true or false?

    ReplyDelete
  5. Wow such an amazing content I really like it. Here is discounted coupon available for you wyze discount code

    ReplyDelete
  6. Your employer can demand a urine drug test if you’re starting a new job. Many employees still live in fear of being surprised by an examination for which they are unprepared. The Urine Drug test is a common procedure in many businesses, even though it might sound like an invasion of privacy. Company drug tests are required for a wide range of jobs, particularly if the nature of the work poses a risk of injury. However, the tests made on hair have the benefits of being indicative of when the drug or exposure to the drug took place. This is why testing the hair from the head is always a priority in most labs. Visit: https://www.urineworld.com/

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thanks for sharing this amazing blog with some unique information keep it up. this was very amazing discount code and delivery much better experience visit at thegosphero discount code

    ReplyDelete
  8. I got know your article’s Content and your article skill both are always good. Thanks for sharing this article this content is very significant for me I really appreciate you. If someone is looking for online course help, trust me these are the best. Have tried many services before but always got disappointed. So I recommend you this website. It’s really helpful How Much Are Online Classes.

    ReplyDelete
  9. We are the most trusted service providers for hiring an expert to assist to Do Exam For Me with any exam topic. Exams are usually a source of anxiety for students since, in the end, your marks will determine your knowledge, and ability to study. You don't have to be concerned about receiving a poor grade. Hire one of our exam takers to complete your exam.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thanks for sharing this amazing blog with some unique information keep it up. hello Fresh discount

    ReplyDelete
  11. We aim to provide students with essay typer , Dissertation writing, Proofreading and Presentation writing services.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Rossana Orange Semi Precious and Fresh Water Pearl Earring are a unique and bold addition to your summer jewelry collection. With tangy orange semi precious stones, large freshwater pearls, and 22k gold plating, these earrings are sure to catch the eye and make a statement at your next summer soiree.

    ReplyDelete
  13. You can easily monitor the progress of your POS Software for Bakery in Pakistan. Furthermore, it allows you to check all of your outlet's data on a single device. Oscar SRB POS collects thorough reports and progress data to assist you in developing future strategies for your bakery.

    ReplyDelete
  14. We offer expert assistance for accessing and optimizing your Wavlink network at wavlink com login. Our team helps you navigate the login process, set up security, and troubleshoot any connectivity problems. Enjoy a seamless and secure Wi-Fi experience with Wavlink technology by relying on our expertise. Visit wavlink.com/login for top-notch support

    ReplyDelete
  15. The Udhaar app is the Best Khata Book App Pakistan, providing an organised approach for all consumers to manage their khata. The wonderful Udhaar simple khata software is the ideal answer for running your dairy store without any faults or blunders. The Udhaar digikhata app allows you to keep track of clients who owe you money and the exact amount he must pay you.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Stone & Pearls Earrings is made of 22k gold-plated brass and includes three magnificent navy blue Mona Lisa stones that are encircled by little acrylic pearls for enhanced beauty and class. Raissa, which means "thinker" or "counsellor" in Greek, is an apt moniker for the woman who wears this earring. The Raissa Earring is more than simply a piece of jewellery; it represents uniqueness, inventiveness, and self-assurance. It serves as a reminder to follow your instincts and to embrace your distinct personality and flair.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Daraz B2B is one of the top and dependable Best B2B Platform for Mobile Accessories in Pakistan. Daraz is a well-established e-commerce platform with a specialised B2B portal for enterprises and wholesalers. You may get a wide choice of mobile accessories at wholesale pricing from Daraz B2B. They provide a simple platform with an easy-to-use interface for browsing and purchasing wholesale quantities of things such as phone covers, chargers, screen protectors, and more.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Oscar POS is a cutting-edge Point of Sale software that has been named the Best POS Software in Pakistan. Oscar POS is an excellent option for business owners who are tired of the problems connected with manual sales monitoring. You may greatly reduce human mistakes throughout the sales process by deploying the integrated Oscar SRB POS system in your restaurant.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Whether you’re a retailer looking to stock your store with top smartphone accessories or a photographer seeking to enhance your mobile photography experience, the Saddar app has you covered. Elevate your photography game, keep your customers satisfied, and explore the world of mobile accessories online through the Saddar app – your partner in providing Top Smartphone Accessories at Wholesale Rate.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Coworking Space for Small Businesses in Karachi provide a collaborative environment where like-minded entrepreneurs may exchange ideas, information, and experiences. Finding an office space for rent in Karachi can be costly for small enterprises and startups. Coworking spaces provide a cost-effective option, allowing businesses to use fully equipped offices without incurring the high costs of establishing a private office.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Coworking Space in Karachi frequently create a networking atmosphere through organised events, workshops, and social gatherings. Members are encouraged to communicate, exchange ideas, and form mutually beneficial connections during these events. The value of networking cannot be overstated, especially for companies looking to broaden their horizons and enter new industries. The collaborative attitude that pervades coworking spaces has the potential to lead to collaborations that convert companies into industry disruptors.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Alibaba.com was a popular Best B2B Platform for Mobile Accessories in Pakistan. Alibaba is a well-known global marketplace that connects suppliers and manufacturers with buyers all around the world. It sells a variety of mobile accessories such as phone covers, chargers, cables, and more. However, the B2B market is fluid, and new platforms may have evolved since then. I advocate undertaking updated research to select the finest B2B platform for mobile accessories in Pakistan based on the most recent market trends and customer ratings.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Work Hall is a guiding light in an era where the workplace is continually developing, providing the ideal location for individuals to do their life's greatest work. Join Work Hall now to go on a path that will lead to success, progress, and an amazing community that will help you achieve your goals. Work Hall is more than just a Coworking Space for Freelancers it is a thriving environment that values variety, creativity, and ambition. Work Hall allows businesses and professionals to reach their full potential by emphasising community, flexibility, and innovation.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Servtec is your key to increasing profitability and accelerating business growth. You receive rapid and efficient access to talent that may alter your operations by using Virtual Co-Workers for accounting and finance tasks. Whether you are looking for recent graduates eager to prove themselves or seasoned US accounting and tax law specialists, Servtec offers the perfect people for the job.

    ReplyDelete
  25. In today's competitive company climate, cost Accountant play a critical role in developing financial strategies, optimising expenses, and assuring long-term success. As organisations adjust to the challenges of the modern economy, strategic staff augmentation has become a cornerstone for effective talent acquisition.

    ReplyDelete
  26. We at Work Hall appreciate the value of a skilled staff. That is why we provide the greatest shared working spaces, including Coworking Space for Freelancers, small enterprises, and sole proprietorships. Our coworking spaces, which include conference rooms and private offices, are intended to accommodate a wide range of company requirements. Work Hall provides the ideal coworking space, where productivity meets comfort.

    ReplyDelete
  27. POS Software for Grocery Store, your primary goals are to create a pleasant shopping experience for your consumers and to remain competitive in the retail industry. To achieve both of your goals, you must upgrade your grocery store's operations with a cutting-edge POS system.

    ReplyDelete
  28. When it comes to buying for high-quality designer items on a budget, https://zeilgroup.com/ in Dubai is a game changer. For less, you may receive simple access to well-known local and global businesses.

    ReplyDelete
  29. SandBox stands out Cheap Coworking Space in Karachi. SandBox offers a flexible workspace option by renting hot desks, private offices, and conference rooms by the hour, day, or month. Members get 24-hour access, high-speed WiFi, and complementary coffee and tea, making it a perfect atmosphere for concentrated work. What distinguishes SandBox is its dedication to community development. SandBox fosters meaningful relationships among its members by hosting frequent networking events, workshops, and speaker sessions. The space's distinctive feature is the ability for potential members to experience the collaborative workspace firsthand through a free trial, assuring a perfect match before committing.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Are you looking for the ideal Shared Workspace for Freelancerthat smoothly combines productivity, creativity, and community support? Look no further than Work Hall, the best coworking place developed just for freelancers like you! operate Hall is revolutionising the way freelancers operate, making it the greatest choice for your professional path, with a wealth of features that cater to your individual demands.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Office Space for Rent for Small Businesses in Karachi provide a collaborative environment where like-minded entrepreneurs may exchange ideas, information, and experiences. This collaborative environment fosters chances for networking, partnerships, and collaborations, all of which may greatly boost business development and success.

    ReplyDelete
  32. https://zeilgroup.com/demonstrates that fashion does not have to be associated with excess. This business redefines the way we think about economical fashion by offering a wide range of used garments in Dubai. It demonstrates that style is not limited by price tags, but rather a personal statement that Zeil Ukay Ukay allows everyone to enjoy.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Being an Average Joe Audiophile is a delightful journey into the world of sound appreciation. grocery coupon cart No need for extravagant setups or high-end gear; just a passion for music and a discerning ear. It's about finding joy in the nuances, savoring the details, and appreciating the artistry of audio on a budget.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Private offices, on the other hand, may be the best option if you value privacy and having your own area. Work Hall providesPrivate Office for people who prefer a quiet and concentrated setting. These offices allow you to personalise your workstation while still enjoying the benefits of being part of a bigger community.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Make a statement with the Allegra dangle earrings. These stunning earrings feature pink and blue semi precious stones, Fresh Water Pearl Earrings and 22k gold plating. With their feminine yet bold design, they are perfect for any special occasion. The combination of pink and blue creates a mesmerizing effect that will catch the eye and make you stand out from the crowd.

    ReplyDelete
  36. We think that Luxury Holidays should be affordable to everyone. Experience luxury without the hefty expenses with our carefully planned Colombia holiday packages. Pamper yourself in the middle of Colombia's stunning scenery and immerse yourself in its colourful culture, all at reasonable prices. Rest assured that we prioritise your pleasure by providing good prices and flights to Bogota or other locations in Colombia without sacrificing the quality of your travel experience.

    ReplyDelete
  37. Customers are drawn to your café by the aroma of freshly made coffee, but it is far from sufficient to meet your business objectives. As a POS Software for Cafe in Pakistan owner, you must attract more customers by offering them the items and services they demand. From a consistent supply of all goods on your menu to quick checkouts. This assists you in gaining loyal consumers. Not only that, but understanding your clients' preferences and reaching out to them appropriately is a vital element of running a successful cafe business.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Zeil Ukay Ukay revolutionises the notion of Preloved Fashion Shops in Dubai a city famed for its excellent living standards. It's more than simply a thrift store; it's a celebration of inexpensive fashion, where each piece has a story and allows people to express themselves genuinely.

    ReplyDelete
  39. Work Hall is a monument to the numerous benefits it provides—innovative workplaces, specialised conference rooms, private offices, and hot desks—all carefully and consciously intended to fulfil the different demands of its members. This bustling centre epitomises the spirit of innovation, efficiency, and cooperation, revealing a way to a future where success for enterprises and freelancers looking for Coworking Space for Rent in Karachi is endless.

    ReplyDelete
  40. Fresh Water Pearl Earrings are perfect for women who want to leave a lasting memory. This stunning piece is crafted with 22k gold-plated brass and adorned with little clear crystals, surrounding a tear-shaped pink quartz stone to add a touch of drama and beauty. The design is completed with two suspended freshwater pearls, adding to the originality and perfect balance of style.

    ReplyDelete
  41. While remote work gives users freedom and independence, it also confronts social contact and cooperation issues. Work Hall's Shared workspaces in Karachi have developed as a refuge for professionals looking to interact with like-minded folks.

    ReplyDelete
  42. Fresh Water Pearl Earrings are ideal for those who wish to create a lasting impression. This gorgeous item is made of 22k gold-plated brass and embellished with little transparent crystals that surround a tear-shaped pink quartz stone, adding drama and beauty. The design is finished with two suspended freshwater pearls, which lend to its uniqueness and perfect balance of elegance.

    ReplyDelete
  43. Work Hall customises itsCoworking Space with Meeting Rooms the different demands of freelancers, startups, and even multinational organisations, from conference rooms to private offices, hot desks, and anything else in between.

    ReplyDelete
  44. The perfect Colombian excursion begins with finding theBest Flight Prices and Uselect Flights assures a smooth journey. As a major travel agent, we offer a user-friendly website for comparing and selecting flights from the United Kingdom to Colombia, catering to all budgets.

    ReplyDelete
  45. AutoCore, with its completeCar Software Repair designed exclusively for auto garages and workshops in the UAE, plays a significant role in improving workshop administration by including real-time data collection.

    ReplyDelete
  46. Virtual interviews and assessments are critical in determining the best candidates for remote tax positions. Use video conferencing platforms to conduct in-depth interviews that assess a candidate's technical proficiency as well as their comfort with Remote collaboration tools.

    ReplyDelete
  47. You may simplify your operations and improve accessibility for both your employees and clients by updating all information in the app and synchronising them with Web based auto repair shop software.

    ReplyDelete
  48. To narrow your search, use phrases like "buying properties in Karachi" and Houses for Sale in Karachi. This guarantees that the findings are accurate and meet your expectations.

    ReplyDelete

Emotiva B1 Review: The Wonderful World of Ribbons (AMT).

Emotiva B1: The Wonderful World of Ribbon (AMT) Tweeters Welcome to my review of the Emotiva B1 bookshelf speakers. With the recent...